Utilization of thyroid nodule images in consultations: secondary evaluation of a pilot randomized study

Abstract Context. Thyroid nodule ultrasound findings are crucial in guiding management decisions for patients with thyroid nodules. However, the frequency with which ultrasound images are discussed and reviewed with patients during clinical visits is not well understood. Objective. To assess how often thyroid ultrasound images are shown and discussed with patients during consultations, and to identify predictors of image review during clinical visits. Design and setting. Secondary analysis of a multicenter pilot randomized clinical trial conducted at two academic medical centers in the United States. Participants. Adults undergoing evaluation for thyroid nodules. Intervention. Participants were randomized to receive either usual care or care enhanced with a conversation aid. Main Outcome Measures. The primary outcome was the frequency of thyroid nodule imaging review evaluated as a binary outcome. Secondary outcomes included evaluation of predictors of image discussion. Results. Eighty-five patients were evaluated. Most participants were women (80%), mean age (60 years, SD 16), and White (86%), undergoing new patient visits (84%). Thyroid nodule ultrasound images were reviewed with patients in 53% of visits (45/85), and in all cases, clinicians initiated the imaging discussion. Predictors of image review included type of consultation (new patient visit) (OR 10.6, 95% CI: 1.79, 62.3). Age, sex, study arm, thyroid nodule size or cancer risk and plan of care (e.g., completing a biopsy) were not statistically associated with review of clinical images. Conclusions. Review of thyroid ultrasound images during clinical visits is relatively common, with consultation type serving as significant predictor.