Abstract / Summary
Skeletal muscle electrical stimulation, delivered as neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) or functional electrical stimulation (FES), is one of very few interventions in heart failure that produces sustained contractile work in the periphery without volitional effort and, in low-frequency configurations, without a measurable rise in cardiac output. Three decades of clinical evaluation have produced consistent signals of improved muscle strength, walking distance and quality of life. The physiological rationale that underpins these observations has advanced much less. This review separates what has been demonstrated in human skeletal muscle in heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) from what has been extrapolated from healthy volunteers, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, critical illness and ageing muscle. We frame stimulation within the muscle hypothesis of chronic heart failure, in which peripheral myopathy drives ergoreflex overactivity, sympathetic excitation and exertional symptoms, and we show that the decisive mechanistic question, whether a programme of stimulation attenuates ergoreflex sensitivity, has never been tested, although two sham-controlled microneurographic studies indicate that stimulation acutely lowers muscle sympathetic nerve activity. Four further gaps are identified: a single biopsy-controlled randomised dataset in advanced heart failure, a single in vivo spectroscopic study in which muscle energetics did not change, absence of contemporary molecular phenotyping of anabolic and proteolytic signalling in stimulated HFrEF muscle, and drift of the recent evidence base towards decompensated, frail and older populations with mixed ejection fraction. Against the background of the 2026 European Society of Cardiology guidelines, which recommend exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation for all stable patients and mention electrical muscle stimulation only as an option for very weak patients, we propose a research agenda in which stimulation dose is reported as a biological variable and muscle afferent physiology becomes the primary mechanistic endpoint.